Lease vs Buy Calculator Guide 2026: Money Factor, Residuals, and the Honest Monthly Math
A lease payment looks smaller because it is paying for less car. That is not a trick โ it is the actual product. The trouble is that lease advertising rarely shows the machinery: the capitalized cost, the residual value, and the money factor that quietly acts as the interest rate. This guide builds the lease payment from its parts with a fully worked example, compares it honestly against buying, and shows the mileage economics that decide which side you should be on.
SECTION 01The three numbers that make a lease
A lease payment = depreciation charge + rent charge (+ local tax). The depreciation charge splits the car's value you will consume: (capitalized cost โ residual value) รท term. The rent charge is the financing cost: (capitalized cost + residual) ร money factor. The money factor converts to APR by multiplying by 2,400 โ so 0.0025 is a 6% APR, and 0.0040 is a 9.6% APR. Any lease worksheet that will not show you the money factor is hiding its interest rate.
SECTION 02The worked example
Car: $30,000 MSRP. Negotiated capitalized cost: $28,000 (yes, you negotiate leases too โ the cap cost is a price). Residual: 60% of MSRP after 36 months = $18,000. Money factor 0.0025 (6% APR).
| Component | Math | Monthly |
|---|---|---|
| Residual value | $30,000 ร 60% | $18,000 |
| Depreciation charge | ($28,000 โ $18,000) รท 36 | $277.78 |
| Rent charge | ($28,000 + $18,000) ร 0.0025 | $115.00 |
| Pre-tax payment | sum | $392.78 |
| At signing | first payment + acquisition + doc fees | $900โ1,400 typical |
Compare the buyer on the same car: $27,000 financed for 48 months at 7% APR is $646.55 per month, and the loan ends with a car worth about $12,900 on the standard depreciation schedule. The lessee paid $14,140 of payments over three years and owns nothing; the buyer paid $31,034 over four years and owns the equity.
SECTION 03The break-even question
The honest comparison is cost per year of ownership, not cost per month. Three consecutive 36-month leases on the example car run roughly $14,140 + taxes and fees each cycle โ call it $4,800โ5,100 per year of always-new car. The buyer who keeps the vehicle eight years spreads $31,034 of payments plus lower insurance and known maintenance across eight years โ and still owns a tradeable asset at the end. The break-even favors buying around the year the loan ends, which is precisely the years most owners keep their cars. Leasing wins when the guarantee matters more than the equity: warranty-covered years, predictable costs, business use.
SECTION 04Mileage is the real contract
Leases price miles explicitly: a typical allowance is 10,000โ12,000 miles a year, with overages of $0.15โ0.30 per mile. A 3,000-mile overage is $450โ900 at walk-away time. A buyer pays for miles too โ through depreciation โ but the market price of a used high-miler is usually kinder than $0.25 a mile. If your commute is long, either buy, or negotiate a high-mileage lease up front (cheaper than overages later).
SECTION 05Negotiating a lease: the three levers
One: capitalized cost โ negotiate it exactly like a purchase price; every $1,000 off the cap cost saves about $28 a month on the example. Two: the money factor โ demand it in writing and compare it to your bank's lease rate; dealers mark it up for profit. Three: the residual โ a higher residual lowers the payment, but check the purchase-option price it implies if you might buy at lease end. Never negotiate the 'monthly payment' number; negotiate the three inputs that produce it. Related reading: the auto loan guide for the buying side, the EV charging cost guide if the lease is electric, and the complete car ownership costs guide for the whole picture.
SECTION 06Scenarios
Scenario 1 โ the commuter. 40 miles a day, 22,000 miles a year. Leasing at 12,000 allowed miles means 10,000 overage miles: $1,500โ3,000 a year in penalties. Buy. Scenario 2 โ the business consultant. 9,000 miles a year, wants this year's safety tech, deducts vehicle expenses. Lease โ predictable, warrantied, possibly deductible. Scenario 3 โ the keeper. Drives cars until the wheels fall off. Buy used at 3โ4 years old, keep eight: someone else paid the depreciation cliff, and this owner never pays it.
๐ Key takeaways
- Lease payment = depreciation charge + rent charge; money factor ร 2,400 = APR.
- Example: $392.78 lease vs $646.55 loan โ but the buyer banks ~$12,900 of equity at loan end.
- Negotiate cap cost, money factor and residual โ never the payment.
- Mileage overages ($0.15โ0.30/mile) make leases wrong for long commuters.
- Leasing wins on predictability and turnover; buying wins on total cost per year.